Recovering a debt in Pakistan: time limits, the suit and execution
A loan, an unpaid invoice or an investment that was to be returned is recovered through the civil court, and the clock usually runs for three years. This note explains the time limits, the summary suit on a cheque or promissory note, and how a decree is enforced.
Chambers
The basics
Money owed under a loan, a sale or a contract is recovered by a civil suit. A criminal case may run alongside where there was cheating or a dishonoured cheque, but the order to pay comes from the civil court.
Time matters more than most people expect. The Limitation Act 1908 gives three years for most money claims, and the period often starts earlier than the lender assumes. For money lent, it runs from the date the loan was made, not from the date of the demand.
Time limits
Money lent
Three years from when the loan was made (Article 57).
Goods sold and delivered
Three years from delivery, or from the end of a fixed credit period (Articles 52 and 53).
Breach of contract
Three years from the breach (Article 115). Six years where the contract is in writing and registered (Article 116).
Cheque or promissory note
Three years. The starting date depends on the instrument and the kind of suit, so treat the earliest possible date as the deadline.
Written acknowledgment
A signed written acknowledgment of the debt, made before the period ends, starts a fresh period from the date it was signed (section 19).
Part payment
A part payment made before the period ends starts a fresh period, provided the payment is acknowledged in the payer's handwriting or over the payer's signature (section 20).
The summary suit
Where the claim rests on a cheque, a promissory note or a bill of exchange, the creditor can sue under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. These suits are heard by the District Court or the High Court, and by other civil courts the High Court has notified.
The defendant has no automatic right to defend. They must apply for leave to defend, on affidavit, within ten days of being served with the summons, and show a real defence. The court can refuse leave, or grant it on conditions such as depositing the amount or giving security. If leave is not sought or is refused, the allegations in the plaint are taken as admitted and the plaintiff is entitled to a decree.
Other money claims follow the ordinary procedure: plaint, written statement, issues, evidence and judgment. A dispute between a bank and its customer over finance goes to the Banking Court under the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance 2001.
What to do
1.Put the documents in date order: the agreement or acknowledgment, bank transfers, invoices, delivery receipts, cheques and return memos, and the messages in which the debt is admitted.
2.Work out the limitation date for each amount, counting from the loan, the delivery or the breach. If it is close, file first and negotiate afterwards.
3.Where the debtor is still talking, ask for a signed written acknowledgment or a dated repayment schedule. It is evidence, and it can restart the period.
4.Send a written demand stating the amount, the basis and a date for payment. Keep the proof of delivery.
5.File the suit: a summary suit if you hold a cheque or promissory note, an ordinary recovery suit otherwise. Ask for attachment before judgment if the debtor is disposing of assets.
6.After the decree, file an execution application. Identify what the debtor owns: bank accounts, vehicles, property and money owed to them by others.
Enforcing the decree
A decree does not enforce itself. The decree-holder applies for execution, and the court can attach and sell the debtor's property, appoint a receiver or, in limited cases, order detention in civil prison. Detention needs more than non-payment: the court must be satisfied, after hearing the debtor, of something such as hiding or transferring property, or refusing to pay despite having the means. It cannot exceed one year, and a woman cannot be arrested in execution of a money decree.
Apply promptly. The first execution application must be made within three years, and no fresh application can be made after six years from the decree.
Points people get wrong
A legal notice does not stop the limitation period running.
An oral promise to pay, or an acknowledgment made after the period has expired, does not revive the claim.
Holding a cheque does not guarantee a decree. The court can still ask what the cheque was given for.
Court fee on a money suit differs by province. In Punjab it is 7.5 per cent of the claim, capped at Rs 15,000.
Common questions
How long do I have to sue for money I lent?
Three years from the date the loan was made, under Article 57 of the Limitation Act 1908, unless a written acknowledgment or an acknowledged part payment has restarted the period.
Can someone be jailed for not paying a debt in Pakistan?
Not for non-payment alone. In execution of a decree a civil court can order detention of up to one year where the debtor has the means and refuses to pay, or is hiding or transferring property. Dishonestly issuing a cheque that is then dishonoured is a separate criminal offence.
Do I need to send a legal notice before filing a recovery suit?
No. The law does not require a notice before an ordinary suit between private parties. A written demand is still useful evidence and sometimes produces payment.
About this note
Reviewed . This note gives general information about the law in Pakistan as at the review date. It is not legal advice, and the right step in a particular case depends on its facts.
To discuss a matter, write to legal@blackwell.com.pk with a short account of what happened. The first conversation is confidential and carries no obligation.