Disputes between business partners and shareholders in Pakistan
When a partner or a majority shareholder takes control of the money or shuts the others out, the remedy depends on whether the business is a partnership or a company. This note sets out the routes for each.
Conference room
The basics
The first question is what the business legally is. A firm of partners is governed by the Partnership Act 1932 and the partnership deed. A limited company is governed by the Companies Act 2017 and its articles of association. The courts, the remedies and the time they take differ for each.
The second question is what the documents say: the deed or shareholders' agreement, the bank mandate, the accounts and the correspondence. Many agreements contain an arbitration clause, which changes where the dispute must go.
Partnerships
Right to accounts
Every partner must give true accounts and full information to the others, and every partner may inspect and copy the firm's books (sections 9 and 12 of the Partnership Act 1932).
Dissolution by notice
A partnership at will can be dissolved by written notice to all the other partners (section 43). In Sindh, a 2023 amendment added a confirmation step before the Registrar of Firms.
Dissolution by the court
Under section 44 the court can dissolve a firm on grounds that include a partner's conduct harming the business, persistent breach of the agreement, the business running only at a loss, or where it is just and equitable.
Settlement of accounts
On dissolution the firm's assets pay outside debts first, then partners' advances, then capital, and any surplus is divided in the profit-sharing ratio (section 48).
Unregistered firm
Under section 69 a partner in an unregistered firm cannot sue the firm or the other partners to enforce the partnership contract, and the firm cannot sue outsiders on a contract. A suit for dissolution and accounts remains open.
Companies
Petition against oppression
Under section 286 of the Companies Act 2017, members holding at least ten per cent of the issued share capital can apply to the Court where the company's affairs are being conducted unlawfully, fraudulently or oppressively. The Court can regulate the company's affairs or order that shares be bought out.
The Court
Company matters go to the Company Bench of the High Court for the place where the registered office is. Ordinary civil courts do not hear them.
Investigation
Members holding at least one tenth of the voting power can ask the SECP, with supporting evidence, to appoint inspectors to investigate the company's affairs (section 256).
Winding up
The Court can wind a company up where that is just and equitable (section 301). It is a remedy of last resort.
Complaint to the SECP
The SECP takes complaints about breaches of company law, such as accounts not being filed or meetings not being held. It does not decide private disputes between shareholders or award compensation.
What to do
1.Collect the deed or shareholders' agreement, the articles, the share certificates, the company's filings, bank statements, accounts, invoices and messages. Take copies before access is cut off.
2.Write to the other side asking for accounts and inspection of the books, and keep proof of delivery. A written refusal is useful evidence.
3.Check the agreement for an arbitration clause. If there is one, a suit can be stayed under section 34 of the Arbitration Act 1940, provided the other side asks before filing its defence.
4.Protect the assets: if the bank mandate allows it, ask the bank to act only on joint instructions, and consider an application to the court for an injunction or a receiver.
5.Choose the route: negotiation and a written exit, arbitration, a suit for dissolution and accounts, or a company petition.
6.If money has been taken dishonestly, consider a criminal complaint for criminal breach of trust or cheating alongside the civil route.
Points people get wrong
The ten per cent threshold in the Companies Act 2017 replaced the twenty per cent threshold of the 1984 Ordinance.
A criminal case does not return an investment by itself. Recovery comes through the civil court, an arbitration award or a settlement.
A partner is personally liable for the firm's debts. A shareholder's liability is limited to the amount unpaid on the shares.
The law on domestic arbitration is still the Arbitration Act 1940. A new federal Bill has been proposed but had not become law at the review date.
Common questions
Can a minority shareholder take a company to court in Pakistan?
Yes, if the members applying together hold at least ten per cent of the issued share capital, under section 286 of the Companies Act 2017. The application is made to the Company Bench of the High Court.
Can I sue my partner if the firm is not registered?
Not to enforce the partnership contract. You can still sue for dissolution of the firm and for accounts, and to realise the property of a dissolved firm.
About this note
Reviewed . This note gives general information about the law in Pakistan as at the review date. It is not legal advice, and the right step in a particular case depends on its facts.
To discuss a matter, write to legal@blackwell.com.pk with a short account of what happened. The first conversation is confidential and carries no obligation.